Tag Archives: I’m Right

Top Ten Tuesday-Books That Deceived Me

Have you ever been tricked by a book? Maybe the cover was wrong or the summary was deceptive. Maybe you were expecting light and fun but got heavy and serious. This trickery isn’t always a bad thing; I have discovered some gems this way. But doesn’t it stink when a book tricks you into believing it’s the best thing since____________(fill in the blank with things like Harry Potter, Hunger Games, Twilight) and it just doesn’t live up to your expectations? Yeah, it happens. Well, this week The Broke and The Bookish want to know which books tricked us. Pay attention and don’t let yourself be fooled!

1. Shine by Lauren Myracle
Why: Don’t be fooled by that gorgeous cover. This is one tough book. It’s amazing, but there is nothing flowery about it.

2. The Ranger’s Apprentice series by John Flanagan
Why: The covers. I mean seriously? This is a book that I would pass over without a second thought. Add in the summaries and it’s a done deal. Not for me…except I decided to pick up the first book because I was worried that I wasn’t reading enough books with strong guy appeal. Oh, man am I glad I did! I cannot gush enough about how amazing these books are. There is action and battles and all that good stuff guys like, but there is also humor and a teeny tiny bit of romance and characters that grow and develop and make you proud. See? Gushing.

3. Revolution by Jennifer Donnelly
Why: It’s historical fiction. This is not my go-to genre, so imagine my surprise to discover that it’s so much more. It’s the past, it’s the present, it’s….oh, I can’t spoil the surprise!

4. Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater.
Why: Because it was supposed to be the next big thing after Twilight. This book elicited very strong, negative emotions. I was also lured in by the pretty, pretty cover. Blah. Not for me.

5. Bloody Jack by L.A. Meyer.
Why: Again, I always think historical fiction isn’t my thing. Also, the covers aren’t that enticing. Well, Jacky Faber is my hero! I love these books (especially the audio) so very much. I want everyone to listen to them. Really, you should.

6. Pop by Gordon Korman.
Why: It’s about football. That’s what you would think if you looked at the cover and read the summary. But really, it’s so much more. It’s sad and funny and heartwarming and heartbreaking. I was so surprised to discover that I had to read this book in one sitting.

7. Amy & Roger’s Epic Detour by Morgan Matson
Why: It’s not all cutesy summer time romance. There is some serious stuff going on in this one. Don’t get me wrong, there is plenty of sweet, kissy, romance, but it’s not fluff. Personally, that’s how I like my sweet, kissy, romances. Fluff free.

8.  Born Wicked by Julie Spotswood
Why: The summary sounds super awesome and the cover is gorgeous. I was so sad to discover I couldn’t even finish it. Slow-paced and flat characters caused me to give up about 50 pages in.

9. All These Things I’ve Done by Gabrielle Zevin
Why: See above. Seriously. Maybe Holly Black set the bar too high for mobster books. I love, love, love her Curse Workers series, which is like The Sopranos with magic. I guess I was hoping for a bit of the same with All These Things I’ve Done. I was so bored I couldn’t be bothered to finish.

10. Blood Red Road by Moira Young
Why: The blurb on the back of the ARC is super cheesy. Also, the dialect was difficult to get used to. You know what? This book is fabulous. I think it got lost in the Hunger Games/Divergent shuffle, which is a shame. I can’t wait for the sequel, Rebel Heart.

So, mostly I have had good surprises. How about you?

Happy Reading!

˜Megan

I’m Right, She’s Wrong…

I read and thoroughly enjoyed Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater. I liked the drama, the action, and the romance of it all. I thought the characters were really very likable and I found the end to be quite satisfying. Megan ,on the other hand, did not care for this book and I’m still confused as to why that might be… Was it how clever the chapters went from her point of view to his point of view? Was it the interesting way the werewolves interacted with each other as a well-developed community? Was it how independent Grace and Sam were from the authority figures in their lives? I liked allllll of that and I liked the clever solution at the end that allowed loose ends to be tied up. I also appreciated the final design choices that made the text color match the icy blue on the cover of the book. It was so simple but so effective. What I liked most of all? That it was such an easy book to read and enjoy, making it hard to put down. That’s why I’m right for liking this book and Megan is wrong for disagreeing with me.

What do you think Megan?

shiver

Well, Stacey, it is true that  I really did not care for this book at all. The cover is totally cool, but like they say, you can’t judge a book by it’s cover. I did not find the characters to be remarkable or even likeable. I felt like Sam was over the top emotional and I was constantly annoyed by his lack of action when it came to dealing with a certain big werewolf problem. All he ever did was talk about this big problem that he really needed to take care of, but he was too busy writing sappy songs for Grace to really do anything about it. Another thing that really bothered me was how independent Grace and Sam were. It was so unrealistic! I mean, there is no way any 17  year old is going to able to buy a car with their dad’s checkbook. And Grace’s so called best friends are nothing but insignificant background characters.

Bottom line, I didn’t connect with any of the characters and therefore did not really care what happened to them. The ending was ok, but not worth the time I spent getting there. That’s why I think I am right.

You have heard two very different opinions. Check out Shiver by Maggie Stiefveter and feel free to take sides!

Stacey, I hear that we have different opinions about Sea Change by Aimee Friedman. Care to go another round of  I’m Right, She’s Wrong?